As the 2025 high school soccer season continues to unfold, Varsity 845 has launched its Player of the Week polls for the week of September 29 to October 5. The contest, which is divided into large and small-school categories, allows fans to vote for the standout performers of the week based on their exceptional efforts on the field. Coaches are encouraged to submit game reports and nominate athletes to ensure their recognition in the weekly poll. The players featured in this article were selected based on reports gathered from Varsity 845, but it is important to note that athletes not appearing in the poll may have been overlooked due to their teams not reporting results.
The Voting Process
The Varsity 845 girls soccer Player of the Week polls provide an opportunity for fans to vote for their favorite players, whether they’re competing at the large-school or small-school level. Voting for the current week is open until Sunday, October 12, at 11 p.m., with results to be announced on the @Varsity845 account on X/Twitter. In accordance with the rules, winners of each week’s contest are ineligible for the following two weeks, which means that players like Haylee Presto of Wallkill and Avery Claudio of Newburgh, winners in the large-school division, and Raquel Mareiros of Highland and Layla Crane of Chapel Field, winners in the small-school division, are currently ineligible.
With that said, let’s take a closer look at the athletes who are in contention for the Week 6 Player of the Week honors for the Sept. 29-Oct. 5 period.
Large-School Nominees
The large-school division features some standout players who have been essential to their teams’ successes over the past week. Here are the nominees:
Ava Boffalo (Pine Bush)
Ava Boffalo of Pine Bush is making a strong case for Player of the Week honors after a stellar performance in a 6-2 win over Goshen on October 2. Boffalo scored three goals in that match, leading her team to a commanding victory. She didn’t stop there, adding another goal in a 3-0 win over Sacred Heart on October 5, further solidifying her spot as one of the top players in the region. Her consistent offensive contributions have been crucial to Pine Bush’s success.
Jayden Ferguson (Middletown)
Goalkeeper Jayden Ferguson from Middletown is a standout nominee, having made eight saves in a hard-fought 1-1 draw with Chester on October 3. Ferguson’s impressive shot-stopping abilities helped keep the game tied, ensuring her team walked away with a valuable point. Her performance as the last line of defense continues to make her one of the best goalkeepers in the large-school division.
Sophia Guido (Goshen)
Sophia Guido of Goshen had a noteworthy week, contributing two goals in a 6-2 loss to Pine Bush on October 2. While the Gladiators came up short, Guido’s individual performance stood out, as she continues to be a critical piece of the Goshen offense. Her ability to score and create chances for her team makes her one of the top players to watch in the large-school division.
Sam Mastowski (Cornwall)
Sam Mastowski of Cornwall has been a force to be reckoned with in the large-school division. In a 7-0 victory over Chester on October 1, Mastowski found the back of the net twice, showcasing her goal-scoring ability. Her performance in this match helped the Dragons extend their winning streak and solidified her place among the top players in the region.
Kayleigh McDonald (Minisink Valley)
Minisink Valley’s Kayleigh McDonald was another standout performer, scoring three goals in a dominant 10-0 win over Monticello on September 30. McDonald’s offensive display was crucial to her team’s impressive result, and her ability to put the ball in the back of the net consistently makes her one of the most dangerous attacking players in the large-school division.
Small-School Nominees
In the small-school division, there are several players who have shown outstanding performances over the past week. Here are the nominees for this category:
Brooke Battiato (Chester)
Brooke Battiato of Chester had a phenomenal performance between the posts in a 1-1 draw with Middletown on October 3. She made 15 crucial saves, keeping her team in the game and ensuring they walked away with a valuable point. Battiato’s performance highlights her reliability as one of the top goalkeepers in the small-school division.
Allyson Chevalier (Tri-Valley)
Allyson Chevalier from Tri-Valley has had an excellent week. Her penalty kick success lifted the Bears to a 4-3 victory over Seward on September 29, and she followed that up with an outstanding four-goal performance in an 8-0 win over Fallsburg on October 3. Chevalier’s offensive output has been key to Tri-Valley’s success, and she continues to be one of the top players to watch in the small-school division.
Francesca Falone (S.S. Seward)
Francesca Falone from S.S. Seward has been a standout player for the Spartans. In their narrow 4-3 loss to Tri-Valley on September 29, Falone scored three goals, showcasing her impressive goal-scoring ability. While the result wasn’t in her team’s favor, Falone’s performance was certainly one to remember, as she continues to be a top offensive threat for her team.
Olivia Gonzalez (Eldred)
Olivia Gonzalez from Eldred was crucial in her team’s 2-1 win over Sullivan West on October 2. Gonzalez made 15 saves to keep her team in the game and secure the victory. Her performance in goal has been a key factor in Eldred’s success this season, and she continues to be one of the top goalkeepers in the small-school division.
Rowan Hubbert (Sullivan West)
Sullivan West’s Rowan Hubbert is another goalkeeper making waves in the small-school division. In a 2-1 loss to Eldred on October 2, Hubbert made an impressive 17 saves, keeping her team in the game and making numerous crucial stops. Her performance despite the defeat shows her talent and determination, making her a player to keep an eye on.
Brooke Huleatt (Mount Academy)
Brooke Huleatt from Mount Academy had a dominant week, scoring five goals in an 8-2 win over New Paltz on September 30. She followed up that performance with six goals in another 8-2 victory over Wallkill on October 3. Huleatt’s offensive output was pivotal in her team’s success, and her ability to score in large numbers makes her one of the most dangerous players in the small-school division.
Talulla Kirschner (Onteora)
Talulla Kirschner from Onteora had an outstanding performance on October 1, scoring three goals in her team’s 11-0 victory over Ellenville. Kirschner’s clinical finishing and goal-scoring ability were on full display, and she continues to be one of the top offensive players in the small-school division.
Isla Morris (Saugerties)
Saugerties’ Isla Morris made 10 saves in a 2-0 shutout win over Red Hook on September 30. She followed that up with nine saves in a 6-0 loss to Lourdes on October 3. Morris’ performance in goal was instrumental in her team’s win over Red Hook, and she continues to be one of the top goalkeepers in the small-school division.
Dayana Ortega (Fallsburg)
Fallsburg’s Dayana Ortega had a busy week, making 10 stops in a 4-0 loss to Middletown on October 1, and then following that up with 15 saves in an 8-0 loss to Tri-Valley on October 3. Ortega’s efforts in goal have been consistent throughout the season, and her ability to stay focused and make key saves is crucial for her team.
Maki Pine (New Paltz)
Maki Pine from New Paltz scored two goals in her team’s 8-2 loss to Mount Academy on September 30. She also added two more goals in a 4-0 win over Red Hook on October 3. Pine’s goal-scoring ability continues to make her one of the top offensive players in the small-school division.
Angelina Schwartz (Rockland)
Angelina Schwartz from Rockland had a standout performance in a 1-0 shutout win over Hunter-Tannersville on September 29. Schwartz made 12 saves to secure the clean sheet and help her team earn a hard-fought victory. Her efforts in goal have been crucial to Rockland’s success this season.
Conclusion
The nominees for Varsity 845 Girls Soccer Player of the Week for September 29 to October 5 showcase the incredible talent and determination found across both large and small schools. Whether it’s a dominant offensive performance or a stellar display in goal, these athletes have proven themselves to be key contributors to their teams’ successes. Fans are encouraged to vote for their favorite players, with the winners to be announced on social media. As the season progresses, it’s clear that these players will continue to make a significant impact on the field.
